Sharing is caring!

Grilled Pumpkin Pie makes for a delicious and smoky dessert. Simply make a standard pie filling, grill indirect for up to an hour, and then serve with a dollop of smoked whipped cream and candied pecans. 

This pie can easily be made Gluten Free and all of holiday ingredients can be found at a one stop location.

Pumpkin Pie is a must for Thanksgiving. It wouldn’t be the holidays without this classic dish. And we have tested several ways to make pies, from classic baking in the oven, to smoking and grilling (and grilling is hands down our favorite). One of the challenges with smoked pie (like pumpkin pie) is the inability to get the right amount of heat that will set the custard filling and make for a flaky crust. So we add smoky flavor by grilling pumpkin pie at a moderate heat and cooking over indirect heat and then using lump charcoal to infuse the flavor.

And with pumpkin pie there are two things that are important to us, aside from using quality ingredients: making sure the spice flavor is balanced, and having the pie filling set for the right texture.

PUMPKIN PIE SPICE

If you buy a pre mixed spice, what you’ll find is basically a ratio of cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. We like to make our own, so that we control the balance of flavors. So we simply follow the same base flavors, but also add ground ginger and kosher salt to round it all out.

PUMPKIN PIE FILLING

This starts with a standard pumpkin pie filling, plus a few elements that add additional flavor and texture for this grilled version.

For grilled pumpkin pie, ingredients matter. Look for the best possible ingredients you can find.

• Pumpkin Puree – This is the base of the whole thing. Buy a good quality canned pumpkin puree (NOT pumpkin pie filling), and make sure to look at the ingredients. Some may not contain 100% pumpkin, so make sure to look. You can also roast your own pie pumpkin on the smoker for great added flavor. Use the same instructions and use the filling in place of a puree if you’re going the smoked pumpkin route.
• Sugar – We like dark brown sugar for its flavor.
• Egg – Egg is one of the key ingredients for the custard filling, and helping it avoid the splitting as it cools.
• Milk – The milk helps with the viscosity and the stability. We use heavy cream as our milk variation because of the flavor and density.
• Spice – Pumpkin pie spices to make sure that the aroma and flavor have that sweet and spicy combination. I love a bold spice flavor, so we tend to go a wee bit heavier on our spices in this recipe. We also add a touch of vanilla extract because we love the added flavor.
• Salt – Don’t forget a touch of salt. A little goes a long way to help balance the sweet and spice.

To make the filling combine the ingredients. We find starting with the egg and sugar creates a nice paste. From there we layer in the additional wet ingredients and then the spices.

Note that the filling will be very runny. Do not be alarmed. It will set as it cooks. If you have a little extra filling after putting into the crust, then simply make a few cupcakes with it.

CRUST

People have strong opinions when it comes to crust. To top if off, our kids are gluten free, which means we would be making two different types of crust from scratch. And let’s be honest, grilling is our thing, not scratch baking. There are plenty of tasty pre-made crusts on the market. So we buy pre-made crust. We have tried this recipe two ways, both blind-baking the crust before adding the filling, and also by just pouring filling in and grilling.

When we blind-bake the crust, the result was an overcooked and crispy crust. This may be more useful when making a dough from scratch, but if you’re buying any kind of store-bought dough, we found this is not necessary. We found the best results in simply pouring the filling into the crust and grilling all at once.

HOW TO GRILL PUMPKIN PIE

To grill a pumpkin pie you need to first start it at a high heat, for up to 15 minutes. This will help allow the custard to set. Then reduce the heat for the remaining time to cook through.

• Prepare grill for indirect cooking targeting 425 degrees Fahrenheit to start.
• Place the pie on the grill at 425 degrees F for 15 minutes, then immediately lower the temperature on the grill to 350 degrees F. Grill temperatures will fluctuate, so ideally keep it between 350 and no higher than 375.
• Continue cooking for 35-45 minutes then remove and allow the pie to sit at room temperature to slowly come down in temperature. You can also insert a digital thermometer into the pie, targeting 175 degrees internal temperature of the pie.

RESTING

Don’t just serve the pie warm, it will fall apart. Let the pie slowly come to room temperature, and cool down for at least two hours. After it’s cooled to room temperature you can place in the refrigerator. This lets the pie slowly cool and not split apart if you go from hot to cold too quickly.

HOW TO CANDY PECANS

We love topping our grilled pumpkin pie with a special touch, like candied pecans and homemade whipped cream. Pecans add the right sweet and bite when they have been candied.

1. Add butter and brown sugar to a sauté pan over medium heat and stir. When it just combines, add the pecans.
2. Stir the pecans, and adjust the heat down if they start to scorch. This stirring will combine and coat the pecans with the sugar and butter combination and toast the pecans.
3. After 8 – 10 minutes, turn off heat and then transfer to a dish or bowl for serving on top of the pie.

We do this while the pie is baking or even resting. Heck, you can even do this the day before.

DON’T FORGET THE WHIPPED CREAM!

Making homemade whipped cream is ridiculously easy. I’ll forgive you for buying a store-bought crust (guilty as charged), but don’t skip the homemade whipped cream! It makes a huge difference. All you need to do is pour heavy whipping cream into a cold bowl (you can also add some vanilla and powdered sugar for flavor and sweetness), then whip away until you get that consistency you like. We love our smoked whipped cream. But even if you don’t smoke your cream, homemade is so much better than store-bought whipped cream!

STORING PUMPKIN PIE

Also think twice before storing the pie at room temperature for too long. The FDA mentions that egg products should be cooled within two hours to avoid any food borne illness. We store our pie in the refrigerator after it cools and it’s ready to eat. Eat the pie within 3 days.

MORE CLASSIC HOLIDAY RECIPES ON THE GRILL

• Bourbon Brined Smoked Thanksgiving Turkey
• Grilled Peaches
• Smoked Sausage, Caramelized Onion, and Cornbread Stuffing
• Red Wine Cranberry Sauce
• Grilled Brussels Sprouts
• Grilled Mashed Sweet Potatoes