Sharing is caring!

An easy and elegant recipe for Smoked Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms cooked on your smoker (or oven). Smoked sausage is the secret to the BEST stuffed mushrooms ever!

These make a great holiday appetizer or for a family gathering! 

What could be better than delicious bite sized stuffed mushrooms filled with savory goodness?

The answer is smoked sausage in that filling!

Add smoked sausage to an already flavorful filling of shallots, garlic, crème fraîche, parmesan cheese (and more), and then smoke the stuffed mushrooms to create the ultimate stuffed mushroom.

Smoking bulk sausage (sausage not in casings) is an easy way to get incredible smoked flavor into a number of meals. A few of my favorites include, smoked sausage and lentil soup, the smoked sausage and hatch chili beer cheese dip(!!!), and smoked sausage lasagna. It’s a great way to enhance some of the classics!

How to Smoke Sausage

1. Take bulk sausage (we recommend spicy Italian if you like big flavor, or mild Italian if you like it a little more mild. I don’t recommend unseasoned sausage.
2. Break it into small quarter-size pieces, and place them on a sheet tray, and onto the smoker, set to 225 degrees, for 45 minutes to one hour. They are done when the internal temperature reads 160 degrees F. Use a Thermoworks MK4 for the best temperature reading.
3. While they are smoking you can work on the stuffing.

We love the Snake River Farms bulk gourmet sausage, it’s savory and a little sweet and an amazing alternative to Italian style sausage you may see at a local butcher.

Once your sausage has cooled enough to work with, dice it into smaller, finer pieces. We want everything to comfortably fit inside the mushrooms without any dominating flavor or large chunks. 

Stuffed Mushroom Filling

• Start by cleaning and de-stemming your mushrooms. We use cremini mushrooms for this (but white button mushrooms are quite similar and work just as well).
• When cleaning and de-stemming your mushrooms, make sure to save those stems and chop them up finely and use them in your filling. No need to discard them. Boom, no waste! This will add more delicious earthy flavors to your filling, added moisture (mushrooms retain a lot of moisture), while keeping you from wasting excess food.
• Next, sauté shallots and those extra chopped mushroom stems in a large skillet until they have softened (around 8-10 minutes).
• Then add the garlic and let it infuse into the mix for about a minute (while also making your house smell heavenly). And now add your sherry.
• After that’s all integrated, remove the pan from heat and mix in the cheese, crème fraîche, seasonings, and remainder of the filling mix and mix together.

A Note on the crème fraîche: It will add a nice creamy texture and a tangy element to the overall flavor. You can sub whole fat Greek yogurt, or cream cheese too (but note that cream cheese is much more dense than crème fraîche, so make sure it’s softened first).

Type of Sherry

Don’t feel like you need to go out and buy fancy sherry just for this mix (though it’s good to have on hand for drinking, and also cooking). Sherry adds a unique flavor that’s such a perfect match for mushrooms (and chicken, and soup, and so much more). If you don’t have sherry, go ahead and use white wine. Chicken stock will work too in a pinch (it just has less of a distinct or elegant flavor). We’re just trying to add a bit of moisture and flavor, that’s all.

How to Smoke Stuffed Mushrooms

It’s time to stuff the mushrooms. Stuff those mushroom caps then put them on a wire drying rack (for ease of transfer), then place them on the smoker for about 45 minutes, or until the caps look soft and delicious and the tops look crisp.

Chef’s Tip: All the meat is cooked, so it’s really about seeing some nice color on the stuffing and the darkening and softening of the mushrooms.

Make sure to serve these delicious savory treats warm. Want an added wow factor? Something we do when catering is a slight drizzle of aged balsamic vinegar. It’s thick and sweet with savory, and an amazing addition of flavor.

Tips for the Best Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms

• The type of sausage you used will make a big difference. We love spicy Italian sausage for the best flavor. Mild is second best. Bulk breakfast sausage will be very mild and slightly sweet, and you will want to jazz it up with more seasonings.
• Crème fraîche may seem like a fancy ingredient, but it adds great flavor and creaminess. If you can’t find it, you can sub softened cream cheese or full fat Greek yogurt.
• Don’t waste your mushroom stems! Chop them up finely and use them in your mix. They add great flavor and texture.
• Use Panko breadcrumbs for the best crunch. Regular breadcumbs will work okay, but Panko have excellent crispy crunch factor.
• GLUTEN FREE?: Substitute gluten free breadcrumbs, crumbled pork rinds (great tip!), or leave them out if you don’t want them at all.
• Use a sharp cheese, like Parmesan, Fontina, or sharp cheddar. You don’t need anything soft (since you have the crème fraîche or cream cheese). So stick with a sharp hard cheeese to add a nutty flavor.

Can I Bake Stuffed Mushrooms?

If you don’t have a smoker or grill but still want these sausage stuffed mushrooms, you can follow these same instructions and bake them in the oven at 375 degrees for around 20-25 minutes, or until the mushrooms look soft and the tops look crisp and delicious.

Wine Pairing

Pinot Noir and anything with mushroom-y or earthy flavors. These flavors are heavenly together. And with the smoky flavor of the sausage I opt for a bigger or richer style Pinot. If there’s no Pinot Noir on hand, I also love Rhone-style wines with this (Syrah or Grenache are nice bets).  

More Appetizer Ideas for the Smoker or Grill

• Goat Cheese Dip with Shiitake Mushrooms
• Smoked Beets with Goat Cheese Ranch
• Grilled Jalapeño Poppers with Brie and Prosciutto
• Baked Brie with Wine and Thyme (on the Grill)
• Grilled Bacon Wrapped Dates with Smoked Honey

If you like this recipe we’d truly appreciate it if you would give this recipe a star review! And if you share any of your pics on Instagram use the hashtag #vindulge. We LOVE to see it when you cook our recipes.

---